The Strategy Paradox

I remember the day my father came home, proudly, with a Betamax videotape player and a movie: Bedtime for Bonzo, starring Ronald Reagan and Bonzo the chimpanzee. Our very first home movie night via videotape ushered in a new era, in which we controlled what we watched.

Move aside TV Guide.

At the time, neighborhood video rental stores were popping up everywhere, and the nearest one to our house was but a short bike ride away. The convenience and affordability of selecting movies and watching them from the comfort of our own home was a new luxury. We could now select the right content (our movie picks), via the right channel (videotape cassette), and watch at the right time (whenever we wanted). That was “On Demand”, ‘80s and ‘90s style…

Be kind, rewind.

I recall vividly that video stores initially offered a wide selection of both Betamax and VHS videotapes. But at some point the balance started to shift, and the Betamax sections of neighborhood stores started to shrink, while the VHS sections grew. Eventually we were relegated to picking movies from just a single aisle, and then from just a couple sad shelves, at which point it became abundantly clear that we had placed our consumer bet on the wrong horse in the race to videotape market dominance.

What happened to Betamax? What led to its rapid surrender of market share to its VHS competition? Was the utter collapse of Betamax the result of an ill-conceived business strategy? Poor execution? Sub-par product? Misunderstanding of its customers?

In The Strategy Paradox: Why committing to success leads to failure (and what to do about it), Michael E. Raynor suggests that Sony’s Betamax suffered from the Strategy Paradox, whereby “strategies with the greatest possibility of success also have the greatest possibility of failure”. Raynor argues that Sony made reasonable commitments in a campaign built for market dominance, in which Betamax was a great product designed to provide customers with the best home movie experiences.

Sony made a strategic bet on product differentiation, by focusing on the optimization of high-fidelity picture and sound quality, at the expense of manufacturing. Matsushita’s VHS, on the other hand, pursued a cost leadership strategy, by offering a cheaper product that was easier to manufacture, and therefore to license.

Sony and Matsushita each hedged their bets on their strategic value propositions, for which there were many trade-offs. For example, with its larger cassettes and slower tape speeds, Matsushita’s VHS offered two-hour recording capability, while Sony’s Betamax tapes were just shy of the two-hour mark, which meant that they couldn’t be used to record two hour broadcast television movie specials.

The Strategy Paradox dissects the Betamax / VHS history in great detail, and also explores many other interesting technological developments, including the transitions from LPs, cassettes, and CDs, to digital media. Further case studies break down the competitive strategies employed by companies such as Microsoft, Johnson & Johnson, and the telecommunications industry.

Ultimately, Raynor lays out a framework that companies can apply to successfully navigate the unpredictable future. He suggests that strategic uncertainty should be managed by hedging bets on possible futures, in order to be best prepared for the unknown yet to come.

Back in the day when I rode my bike to the local neighborhood video store to pick up a movie rental, I was keenly aware of the shifts in product selection as a consumer. But I was oblivious to the cutthroat competition that was taking place between Betamax and VHS. There are many lessons to be learned here, with respect to product differentiation and company strategy, and if you’re curious to dig deeper into these questions, challenges, and mitigating solutions, I recommend checking out The Strategy Paradox.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s